Shake or stir
If everything in the drink is clear and alcoholic, stir it. If there is juice, egg or cream in it, shake it.
Both do the same two jobs: they make the drink cold, and they melt some ice into it. That water is an ingredient. Roughly a quarter of a finished drink is melted ice, and without it the drink tastes harsh.
The difference is texture. Stirring keeps a drink clear and silky. Shaking beats air and tiny chips of ice into it, which makes it cloudy and lively. That suits citrus and would spoil a Martini.
| Method | How long | Use it for |
|---|---|---|
| Stir | 20 to 30 seconds | Old Fashioned, Negroni, Manhattan, Martini |
| Shake | 10 to 12 seconds, hard | Daiquiri, Margarita, Whiskey Sour |
| Build in the glass | One gentle stir | Paloma and anything topped with something fizzy |
How to tell it is done
- Stirring: the outside of the mixing glass is cold enough to be uncomfortable to hold.
- Shaking: the metal frosts over and the sound of the ice changes from a rattle to a duller slosh.
The first shake without ice
Drinks with egg white get shaken twice. The first time, with no ice, whips the egg white into a foam. The second time, with ice, chills and dilutes as usual. The Whiskey Sour page walks through it.